Kim Scott introduced a useful 2x2 matrix to help us understand our habits around giving feedback (or avoiding to do so). Let’s see how we can make our feedback more effective and meaningful.
The matrix has two axes:
- Horizontal: Challenge directly (right) vs. Avoid giving feedback (left)
- Vertical: Care personally (top) vs. Don’t care about the other person (bottom)
This creates four quadrants, to which I added food metaphors to make them more memorable:
- Ruinous Empathy (top left): We care about the person but avoid difficult conversations to spare their (and our own) feelings, leading to unaddressed issues. Like a sugar-coated donut, it's sweet but lacks substance.
- Obnoxious Aggression (bottom right): We bluntly express our frustrations without empathy, resulting in hurtful interactions. This is like a chili pepper—fiery and intense but overwhelming.
- Manipulative Insincerity (bottom left): We withhold feedback to see others fail, often for self-serving reasons. Think of it as a hotdog full of empty calories and hidden additives—tempting but ultimately unhealthy.
- Radical Candor (top right): We provide honest feedback with genuine care, fostering growth. It's like a salad—nourishing and beneficial, even if tough to chew at times.
A simple experiment
Reflect on the past two weeks: Have you given sugar-coated feedback (donut) to avoid difficult conversations? Follow up with sincere, constructive feedback (salad) instead. You’ll both feel better afterward.
If you want to receive visualized concepts like this with simple experiments in your inbox when they come out on Monday mornings, sign up at visuals.newworkbydesign.com
Comments ()