In previous issues, we’ve covered Theory X vs. Theory Y, Extrinsic vs. Intrinsic Motivation, and the four pillars of intrinsic motivation: autonomy, mastery, purpose, and belonging.
It’s easy to think of extrinsic motivation as the opposite of intrinsic motivation—either you enjoy what you do, or you’re just in it for the paycheck. But the latest research in Self-Determination Theory (SDT) reveals a more nuanced reality. Instead of a simple extrinsic vs. intrinsic divide, motivation exists on a spectrum with different levels of internalization.
Turns out, extrinsic motivation isn’t just about rewards or punishment—it can evolve into something deeper and more personal:
⚫ Amotivation – The absence of motivation. “I might be on time. I don’t care if I’m late.”
🔴 External Regulation – The carrot-and-stick approach. “I have to be on time or my boss will yell at me.”
🟠 Introjection – Driven by pressure and shame. “I should be on time so people don't think I'm irresponsible.”
🟡 Identification – You personally value the behavior. “I choose to be on time because it keeps things running smoothly.”
🟢 Integration – The behavior becomes part of your identity. “I am a punctual person. Being on time is how I show reliability.”
⚪️ Intrinsic Motivation – Joy and satisfaction. “I enjoy being on time and feeling prepared for what's next.”
The Motivation Shift
Most tasks in life will never be truly intrinsically motivating—and that’s okay! The key is not to force joy but to shift from external pressure to internal meaning.
Take taxes, for example. Will I ever enjoy doing them? Probably not. But instead of staying stuck in demotivation, I’ve found ways to move toward identification—and with a bit more effort, maybe even integration. 😁
🟣 Demotivation – “I hate doing my taxes.”
⚫ Amotivation – “I might do them today… or not.”
🔴 External Regulation – “I have to do them, or I’ll get fined.”
🟠 Introjection – “I should do them to be a responsible citizen.”
🟡 Identification – “I choose to do my taxes because I value the society I live in.”
🟢 Integration – “I am a responsible citizen who contributes with their taxes.”
⚪ Intrinsic Motivation – “I enjoy doing my taxes.” (Okay, let’s be honest… this is out of reach 😆)
🧪 A Simple Experiment
This week, try this with your team (or yourself) to make an uninteresting task more engaging:
✅ Explain why it matters.
✅ Acknowledge that the task isn't fun.
✅ Ask for help instead of demanding it.
You’ll be surprised how much motivation shifts when people feel less controlled and more supported in their autonomy.
🤓 Fun Fact
During the HI-SEAS IV Mars simulation, astronauts experienced a gradual loss of autonomy and connection—not just with loved ones on Earth, but even with their own crew members. As the yearlong mission progressed, feelings of isolation and defiance toward mission protocols increased. However, when Mission Support used an autonomy-supportive communication style, astronauts reported higher motivation, better cooperation, and less stress. In other words, how mission control talks to astronauts can make or break long-duration space missions! 🚀👨🚀
🤔 What If…?
What if motivation worked like Wi-Fi—broadcasting energy levels to those nearby? Imagine stepping into a meeting and instantly feeling charged up just by sitting next to the most enthusiastic person in the room. Workplaces would have "motivation hotspots" where high-energy employees naturally lifted everyone around them. And on lazy days? You’d just need to find the right “signal boost” from a highly motivated colleague. 📶✨
(🤓 Fun Fact inside the What If...? Motivation is actually contagious.)
If you want to receive visualized concepts like this with simple experiments in your inbox when they come out on Monday mornings, sign up at visuals.newworkbydesign.com
Comments ()